Oyster Bay

Eat in the vaulted, airy dining room or in the buzzy cherry wood bar. Either way, this is a Cape May classic.

WHERE IS IT? On Lafayette Street, opposite the Acme.

WHY SHOULD I GO? Oyster Bay invites you to savor their extraordinary menu. Renowned for impeccably grilled steaks and local seafood, this dining haven captures the essence of coastal charm.

Indulge in succulent dishes like Andouille Crusted Grouper or a 12-ounce NY Strip amidst an inviting atmosphere in the dining room or bar. And you can’t pass up their extensive wine list packed with reds and whites to suit any palate. Whether an intimate dinner or a casual gathering, Oyster Bay promises a delightful experience.

With attentive service and a commitment to quality from, Oyster Bay is a must-visit destination in Cape May’s vibrant culinary scene. Join them for a gastronomic adventure.

INSIDER TIP The menu changes seasonally — given that Oyster Bay is open 10 months of the year, there’s plenty of chances to give it a try!